We suspected this was fake, but now Defamer finds proof. You know what this means … Photoshop contest, Ashlee Simpson stizz!
Take the original and Photoshop something funny into Hilary’s bag. A dildo, an Arcade Fire CD, a Lindsay Lohan voodoo doll, whatever! Do your worst, and e-mail the jpeg to scott @ stereogum.com.

We’ll post the best ones here on Wednesday.
%s1 / %s2







































A dildo, an Arcade Fire CD, a voodoo doll… aww, you mentioned the best ideas! Now we gotta think even harder? Sheeeeit.
off topic: her pants are hideous.
Hilary………I thought you were a good girl!
Is that little guy her boyfriend?
Whatever, she’s wearing black lace undies; she’s totally having sex. Which is still gross. God help us all if she spawns a new race of chunky cheerleaders.
my lord, STEREOGUM, OH LORD ALL MIGHTY PLEASE! somebody needs to announce that CHRISTINA AGUILERA is NOT MARILYN MONROE and also that she is a big immitator and omg it’s horrible..she even draws a dot on her face AND she EVEN SHAPES HER EYEBROWS THE SAME! please STEREOGUM! for the good of humanity please..TELL THEM ITS WRONG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! and she will never amount up to anything other than a pop”DIVA”/imitator! PLEASE!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
the “proof” link isnt working
> the “proof” link isnt working
fixed!
What did Hilary ever do to you guys?? (I mean, besides having those disgustingly fat arms)
god, I guess I just don’t see that whole “condom” thing. Looks to me like a tin of lippy. Hm?
“Oh my gwad I like get sooooo many ideas for rockin’ songs and I like carry a tape recorder in my bag so when an idea for like a totally punk song comes on me I can record it”
The proof button isint working again. Fuck it, atleast she is using rubbers. Have you people seen that hideous fucker that is her bf? Joel Madden or whatever. I wonder how she manuvers around all of that shit stuck in his face.
what’s with the aaron carter look-a-like? is that really her boyfriend? since when did shaggy, pimply, 13 year old wannabe pimps become the hot new bf?
Gotten some good ones so far…
You can keep sending ‘em today. I’ll post the best ones TOMORROW instead of today.
i have to agree with brooke. i don’t see a condom (via the “proof” link). as much fun as it will be to see the photoshopped pics (and i’m looking forward to it), gossip.com or whoever it is trying to pass off that fake as legitimate is an ass.
I heart Hillary
what the fuck is your guys problem she is just hangin out with her damn boy friend(god damnit) and my professional opinion is that omgno! is jealous of her being a celebrity or some shit like that. kate and Noah need to start dealin with their own fuckin problems like the fact that they haven’t had a relationship since they were in kindergarden. And how can sdfsdf even focas on the “pants” when she is wearing them.
lover has a good point and the right perspective on life?and to end with catch my phrase
smokin, drinkin, an havin fun
good stuff. I’m excited to see peoples’ results. I posted a couple of mine at http://blog.verbosecoma.com/archives/000814.php
Yall stop mess’n wit hilary she is so pretty…n so talented…some people r just jelous n try 2 make her look bad!
pp tastw good
nice butt
seriously nice A$$
Wow!!!!!
Cha-Ching
i am the coolest i have had relathions with hiliary!!!!
how is it really proof, when you can just photoshop something out of a picture and get an even larger number of hits on your fake photo?
Fuck all of you. None of you know anything about HILARY, which by the way, Lover, thats how u spell her name. You all are just jealous of her. And u wish u could be with her. By the way, that isnt her boyfriend, you idiots, because she is currently single. Oh yeah, Bob? You seriously need to get a life. You only wish you had “relations” with her. Oh, Kate? Just because she’s wearing black lace “undies” doesn’t mean she’s having sex. Maybe for u it does because you are probably a whore!!!
Fuck all of you. None of you know anything about HILARY, which by the way, Lover, thats how u spell her name. You all are just jealous of her. And u wish u could be with her. By the way, that isnt her boyfriend, you idiots, because she is currently single. Oh yeah, Bob? You seriously need to get a life. You only wish you had “relations” with her. Oh, Kate? Just because she’s wearing black lace “undies” doesn’t mean she’s having sex. Maybe for u it does because you are probably a whore!!!
hilary you look really good!and if thats your bf he he is really hott
you look very sexy+++++++++ and your underwere are showing
I have to agree with those in favor with Hilary, i met her at this arena that i work at when they threw a concert, she is pretty and nice, and even though this picture is a fake and even though she might really be having sex, i mean why not? everyone does it, EVEN YOU!!! She isn’t fat either…not everyone in this world has to be a perfect britney spears to be beautiful and succesful….jerks…
Hey everyone where am i????
Look kate and noah no1 is perfect not me not both of u and not even Hilary and about the condom thing i don’t really care if it’s true or not the people that would know if it is true or not is Hilary and the person who took the photo.
ok all of you are retarded… its her business- if she wants to have sex- big deal! and if she is wearing black undies it means NOTHING. You definetly watch too much tv and talk rumors about people. shes not fat and you all need to stop talkin bout her- shes the one person in our society that isn’t anerexic and praise the lord that there is someone out there today that people can actually look up to. i think shes doing a great job and fuck the condoms- at least shes not gonna get prego or anything. shes a big girl and can make her own decisions. and the photos fake anyways. so you all need to stop talkin crap and get over the fact that shes better than all of you! -haterz. and to all of you who supported her- thanks guys!
Pls.. those people who just want to insult nice people like Hilary.. cm’ on and get a life.. asswholes… U’ve got no right to offense people u don’t even know.. so don’t act like dumbasses and respect those who deserve it.. if u want, u can insult trhough u.. but don’t fuck with great humans, that do a nice job in this world to make it better… Hilary rocks, u all suck!!… (the ones that have insulted her
)
Hey guys! It’s me Hilary, you guys really heart my feelings, you shouldn’t judge people for what they are wearing or who they’re with or how they look. I know you guys won’t believe that I’m actually Hilary but I just want to say that the guy I was with is my step cousin, and no I’m not have sex and the underwear I was wearing was the only underwear that I had in my droor because all of my other undies were dirty. Buy guys!
Hey guys! It’s me Hilary again! I just wanted to thank Clau_hde_admi, I really appreciate for you sticking up for me. Thankyou! It means alot! But I just wanted to say something if you could stop swearing just a little in your sentences no disreaspect. But thankyou for sticking up for me! Luv ya!
Hey Hilary
Don’t take the things that people are saying about u I personaly think is really wrong. It is like a old saying: Take it like a grin of salt
love nick bye
Yea I agree with cla_hde_admi you should not say things about people you dont know like c’mon you would not like people saying thins about you behing your back would you, yous are just jealous that hilary is very pretty and talented in singing and acting and you just cant accept that so you call her things that are not true
Why even waste your time to pretend that you are Hilary Duff? What a loser!
Hilary Duff is gay
STOP pretending Hilary u asswhole!!!!!!!!!! And why u guys don’t like Hil?? MABIE BECOUSE SHE IS SOPO OWSOME, PRETTY AND TALANTED??? then screw u!!! She is the cutes girl in the whole world!!! and she is soooo owsome….I looooooove her!!!
is there something wrong with liking arcade fire?
wat a bullshit look Clau_hde_admi said he/she was hilary duff then u look at the second message and it said hi its hilary again so again it means ”she” posted again so in the previous message that was hilary but then she goes and says i wanna thank Clau_hde_admi so it measn they r not hilaryd ytf would she thnk herself ooo and if u look who posted the messages they got 2 whole diff emails so u guys are fucked and plz dont pretend to be someone else be yourself and go see a doctor cuz i think u 2 got some fuckin problems in the head, ooooo and also bfore i go i wanna say all u haters here on the site jus shut up cuz yalll prob some fucked up 16 year olds who wish to have hilary riddin u cock but in reality it would neeeeever happen cuz u guys r fuckin losers and cant get no life and hilary looks very good how the fuck are heer arms fat, i dont c shit, black panties wow soo its like i can say if u wear a white tanktop ur fuckin gay. thats arron carter in the background and he aint her bf cuz they broke up at 14 or 13 id ont member but they did anwyas only god can judge them so al u haters jus shut up oo ye and remember W.H.A.T G.O.E.S A.R.O.U.N.D C.O.M.E.S A.R.O.U.N.D
hello hilary will you marry me? i just want to fuck you all day and i want to love all my life thanx p.s i love you hilary
hello hilary will you marry me? i just want to fuck you all day and i want to love all my life thanx p.s i love you hilary
Whats up everyone! Hilary is my idol and she never did anything to you guys for you to bad talking her.All the people who support her are so awsome!Some of you need to stop hating and take a look at the real world.She is so pretty and she can date anybody she wants.
I love Hilary Duff, everyone needs to stop talkin about her and mind their own business, if u dont liek her, o well, u dont need to tell every1 about it! Dam!!!!!! shes 1 of the only actresses who isnt anerexic….
I just want to say that i am australian and that i really want to know what hilary duff’s msn address is? So if you are really out there Hilary my msn address is blaize_141392@hotmail.com please add me, and i would also like to say, i think you are the best and that who cares what people think about you, that’s there opinion and you shouldn’t care, by the way i am over 15,(if you wanted to know)and good looking.
The guy in the background is her cousin, Marco Milano. If that’s not enough proof, check for yourself. http://groups.msn.com/HilaryandHaylieDuff/hilarysfriends.msnw
Thank you, Victor, I’m glad to see someone knows that is not her boyfriend there, but her cousin! It was killing me thinking NOBODY thought to look into the girl before judging her, heh heh. Hm…such is our nature, eh?
Hey, sign me up for some of that!
hilary duff i live in calgary my name is peyton and im 8 years old i would do anything if you cdould come to my house and meet me and my family my borther thinks your cute my 2best frind would like to meet you to!!!please i beg of you to e-mail me at peytonpp_15@hotmail.com maybe we could talk to each other on line
Hey hilary me birky and who cares what other people think of your underwear ur still gunna be the hottest girl alive
add this email…..knuckle_head5@hotmail.com
thanks love yah
At least the boyfriend is white…
who it that boy!!??
Hilary you are a beautiful girl no matter what people said they are just jealous about you. You inspired me I like to thank you for that.
If you have time write me at miloudenis@hotmail.com I would loved that peace
first of all that other girl named hilary should stop trying to be me, that guy in the photo is my friend marco. I love him so much. And then the underwear noofence to u guys but thats they way the underwear is made so u can see them. I love all my fans and i thank the people that back me up. Here is what i have to say for the people who have a dream- never give up on ur dreams, if u dream big my ur dream a reality. I mean i always dreamed of being an actress when i was smaller and look where iam now. I never gave up and u shouldnt either.I luv yall xoxo hil.
Hey Hilary
This your boy L.L. Imma big fan of your series boo. All yall hattin ass girls out there need to stop fakin and look in da mirror. If we even saw half of yall skanks, yall would have to cook yourselfs. Anyways Hillary dont listen to those wannabee internet thug haters.
kisses and hugs boo
holla back Hillary
Hey, I have been watching Hilary since I was since she was in lizzy. I have loved her I have always wanted to go out with her. I will be famouse and I want to meet her. You guys are just mad at her becouse you are not rich like her. It is not easy. We have to work our buts off to be where we are today. Hilary is following her dream and she is rich and famous ver soon I will be also. Hilary email me if it ireally you on this site. And if she wants to have sex big deal. Its not like most of you havent anyway. I have been made fun of most of my life it just made me stronger. I dont know if it was the same for you hilary, but I am going to show all of the people who gave up their dreams and started making fun of people spreding rumors and trying to get others to give up their dreams what I am made of. Hilary please email me if it is really you.
Hey Hilary i love u and even if u have sex its all right with me wee should meet some time come to wisconsin please i love u!!!! bye
P.S.
Hey maybe we can party and then we can have sex and i can do u up the butt annd even eat out on u and lick ur sweaty armpits after hope they arent shaved either so they smell to love you bye
Hey i jerk of to me i just wanted to say im coming to Wisconsin some time and you should give me your number so i can call u and pick u up and i wont shave my armpits for u and i wont wear deoderant so when we are having sex u can lick my armpits and do me up the ass and in my pussy i love u bye
hey hilary we all know that is not you. Just give it up. you people are sick. Hialry is hot but for one thing we all know she is a virgin you ass munchers just like to pread rumers. 2. hilary (the last one on june 7) Hilary would never talk like that you sick twisted ugly slutty skanky bitchy bottom feeding trash bag hoe. Tell me something why are all of you ass mongloids spreading rumors?
hey hilary we all know that is not really Hilary. Just give it up. you people are sick. Hialry is hot but for one thing we all know she is a virgin you ass munchers. You sick little shits just like to spread rumers. 2. hilary (the last one on june 7) Hilary would never talk like that you sick twisted ugly slutty skanky bitchy bottom feeding trash bag hoe. Tell me something why are all of you ass mongloids spreading rumors? The only people who spread rumors are lonely low selfesteemed people. get over it.
imagine u were a freakin celebrity…would u like ppl to talk shet about u and juge every of ur moves etc??….when u were black underwears…do u find it wrong??? when u wonna be pretty look nivce do u find it wrong?? hello ppl get a life…try to realise that u on planet earth and that u live right now…and y do u try to be so hypocrite and stupid …. dont let ur jealousy get through ur thoughts….hilary duff is a human being dat comes up to be a famous celebrity……wats wrong with it if she has a condom or not if she wears black underwears dat show?? and if da guy next to her its her bf?? wats freakin wrong with that?? she has the right to do wtv she wants….imagine u were a celebrity damn it…u r all(the ones that insult without any reason) soo ignorants and analphabetiques jeezz……she has da right to do wtv she wants as soon as she has her limits…and i can say dat she is a really normal girl … think be4 talk guys just think
Hilary Duff rocks, you guys are all stupid.
Stop spreading rumors and lieing. Hil is a good girl, I’m a big fan, I know!!!!!!!!!!!
Hey, I agree with Hilary even if there is a chance that it isn’t her, quit swearing so much there are better words and stay out of her personal life it’s her buisness. How would like it if people were talking about you like that on the internet where everyone can see it.
AND THAT PICTURE OF THE CONDOM IS SO FAKE!!!!
Hilary if you really are on this site email me on danielle_animal_lover@hotmail.com
P.S I want to be famous singer just like you
keep up the good work.
I believe it was you who emailed the chatroom.
That’s not her boyfriend! Duh that’s her cousin/friend Marco don’t you ever watch Disney and she would not under any circumstances sleep with her cousin that’s just wrong in SO many ways.
HEY WHO EVER YOU ARE IMPERSONATING HILARY AND MAKING HER LOOK BAD GET LOST SHE WOULD NEVER TALK LIKE THAT AND YOU KNOW IT I ONLY SAID I BELIEVED IT WAS HER BECAUSE I DIDN’T SEE THE ENTRY FROM THE SEVENTH OF JUNE. AND DON’T EMAIL ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
EVERYONE JUST LEAVE HILARY ALONE IT’S NOT NICE YOU WOULDN’T LIKE IT DONE TO YOU WOULD YOU.
well well well…another fucking worthless piece of shit site? where you can talk about Hilary huh? where it makes you feel good to talk shit about her huh? you are yourselfs are worthless cockroaches who have no life but except sitting in their rothouse in front of their monitors.
what’s the problem with sex? sex is a natural thing u fuckfaces, having it at whatever age or whatever time is person’s personal desicion. wow, a black underwear, she must be a slut! well u stupid fucks, that’s what u put on, u call that an underwear, u kno that? ye, u call that an underwear, ye that, what she is wearing in the picture, that is called an underwear. what u dont wear one? i am sorry, girls have a different design of it, change ur sex then. i apologize about the excesive swearing, it did not apply to all of u. i go now, bye.
oh ye, i love you Hil. go all of the way baby!
Hey Hils
remember well We met couple months ago in Ottawa at your concert anyways. Im not sure if you have gotten a new email address or not cuz the one I have your barely ever on so just email me back and give me your new one you have if you do I would appreciate it thanks a ton
Drew
hey hilary don ot feel bad those s.o.b s because they do not know who you really are. i really luv you and i think you are very hot and sexy. those fuckers keep insulting you and i do not like it cause i feel hurt. it looks like they are insulting my sister.plz read this letter and reply or give me your id to wordlife_aman@yahoo.co.in
Have u guys ever thought that maybe it was a tampon in her bag? I tell you, papparazzi.
ok, why do you guys hate hilary duff so much. i mean have you met her, has she disrespected you in some way. or are you guys just gothic junkys that dont know good music when you hear it. and another thing. its not hilary to you guys you dont know her and you are not her friends so thats hilary duff. why dont you guys go do what your good at go sit on a couch and be mad at the world because you know what thats the only thing you closet junkies know how to do.
Fuck Hiraly Duff Ill Bone That Bitch
Fuck Hiraly Duff Fuck Her Up Her Stupid Ass Ill Make Her Eat My Shit That Will Come Out Of Her Shit That Will Be Made Out Of Me
i wanna fuk hillary so hard in ass ahh yah yah
hey..;.wat is she stiil doin dere with aaron caeter,i thought dat joel madden 4rm good charlotte is her boyfren
I Hate you All
hey Hilary waz up how ru dont let enybody hart you becuse u r a nice young lady by the why do u trip a bout stuff what time was that pic taking of you and your cusion from RPB
hilary i have this friend that whats this girl really bad and he siad he would not stop liking her if u have time e-mail me at darkangel_420_84_69_2005@yahoo.com from RPB PS be happy becuase you are hot!!!
You guys seriously need to chill… First off, I DOUBT Hilary is reading this crap, so you are TOTALLY wasting your time…. (its kind of pathetic if you think about it….) Secondly, I dislike Hilary as much as the next person, but you all are going out of your way to destroy this girls life by doing ridiculous things like that…. And whether she is have sex or not should be none of your concern, unless you’re the one she’s sleeping with…. Lastly, where can i find the photoshop contest pictures??!
I think hilary looks cute I would give anything to have her body and most os you’ll are just jelous of what she has and what you’ll don’t I wish I could be like her
I think hilary looks cute I would give anything to have her body and most of you’ll are just jelous of what she has and what you’ll don’t I wish I could be like her and have as much talent as she did so all you’ll hater need to stop hating
hilary waz up i wanted to ask when is your new movie is coming out and can u help me out i like this girl and how do i get her to like me back becuase she a real good girl and i really like her so what sould i do. from RPB
i think hilary is the hottest girl on earth. its really nobodys buisness of what she wears and what she doesnt wear or what she does and what she doesnt do. and if she ever need someone to talk to she can email me at justindamon148@msn.com
i’m not a total fan of Hilary Duff…but she isnt fat..i dunno why people are saying she is.. i mean maybe she isn’t that skinny in the “world of the stars” but in the real world she isn’t fat. Stop hating on sumone you dont even know. If she is having sex thats her business…why do u care?
oiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiiii seu flog ta massa sou ligada na hilary duff
Looks like sunglasses to me, or the case for them.
Fuck you all.
i wanna fuck her up the ass really bad, no condom needed
Hi hilary i am a fan and continue your job you are so good. if you have time make me a reponse … when you have a new movie ?
me e-mail is jean-michel_coulome@hotmail.com
OFFSPRING IS THE BEST AND HILARY DUFF TOO
and vegeta is the best
Hey hil you rock and my little sister thinks your awsome cause of your show, but hey ignore what the people are saying i think they are just lowlifes, but hey how hard is it to get into the music buisness cause me and my friends are starting a band?
P.s. Email me at dude__sk8t_sean
Hey hil you are asome listen me and my friends are making a band so maybe when i get all the way to the top like you we can sing songs together it seems like i know you well i practily do i have everything of yours your cds and bed spreeds and even cards any ways keep up the good work ok bye email me @ jbusbin@tampabay.com ok I hope your not a snob like the other famouse people are ok gotta go bye
to be honest u are all sad, yeah hilary duff is having sex, but y do u give a shit? just cause shes famous she can still have a life, how would u like it if loads of people started bitching about u! grow up!
Hey you guys
WHY do must of you talk about how much you hate hilary and continue to go on this website?????? like c’m on. I think hilary is great and you should stop talking about her. S he is soo sweet and who cares what panties she is waring or who she is going out with or if she is having SEX it is her bussiness. And you sad people that think you are hilary well you need to get a life.
hey hilary call me i wanna see ya
hey hill if u visit this site plz say something cuz i hate that boy next to u cuz i wanna be next to u i 8 tall womens so post something i… well all of u fatties seeing this shit start wrokin out fat ppl r groose oh and hil is not fat shes a women and womens have 20% more fatness in their body’s than mans so thats for u nerds to shut up i also hate skinny womans and cats and fly’s and condom its like eatin a candy with the plastic on
oh i always wanned to meet u since like 10 years old and i would love to chat with u ps:i hate to chat and i dont go to msn like 2 weeks but with u it would be an honour also im not 10 years old im 15 and my birthday is 27 aug so u could give a few words as a gift iam 5.6 124pouds green eyes ligth brown hair kinda musceled portuguese and pretty il give u some pictures if u want to know how i am just say how do u want me to be if u wanna a strip u have to pay
just kiding i think heres my mail ask me what ever u want i dont charge… f_a_c_a90_4@hotmail.com plz. i know u wont be my girlfriend and im not a lunatic im just crazy