It’s a crazy post-Stop Peter Bjorn & John world we’re living in. Got a problem with an indie rocker? Start a blog about it! Dave writes in to tell us about a slow-brewing blog beef between some dude who claims to have had his basketball stolen by Win Butler (find him at arcadefirestolemybasketball.blogspot.com), and Butler-brother Will, who claims that, in fact, Arcade Fire didn’t steal this dude’s basketball (and you can find him at arcadefiredidntstealdudesbasketball.blogspot.com).

Given this is all entirely unsubstantiated internet hearsay, we’d like to add this fact to the controversy: In the recent Rolling Stone (P. 67, para 2, Issue 1027 — Depp/Richards cover), Win told Gavin Edwards that “he tries to play basketball at least once a week, even on tour“! (Emphasis added for additional sensationalistic effect.)

Sounds like Win is totally guilty.

Comments (157)
  1. Colin  |   Posted on Jun 7th, 2007

    Built to Spill crashed my tupperware party, knocked a glass of wine over onto the sofa and then wrote a 12-minute song about it.

  2. Justin  |   Posted on Jun 7th, 2007

    Clap Your Hands Say Yeah tried to sing to my girlfriend.

  3. Justin  |   Posted on Jun 7th, 2007

    Clap Your Hands Say Yeah tried to serenade my girlfriend.

  4. Fiona Apple fingered my cat

  5. robocups  |   Posted on Jun 7th, 2007

    black rebel motorcycle club is playing at my house…my house!!!

  6. pandy  |   Posted on Jun 7th, 2007

    Murder City Devils emptied my bottles and broke my heart.

  7. Greg  |   Posted on Jun 8th, 2007

    Arcade Fire stole my virginity.

    But I left my wallet at their house so I can see them again. Suckers.

  8. tina  |   Posted on Jun 8th, 2007

    Brian Jonestown Massacre fuckin broke my sitar, motherfuckers.

  9. shifty  |   Posted on Jun 8th, 2007

    Boards of Canada didn’t do anything to me.

    That sucks.

  10. Savin Hill teleported me to China.

  11. that one kid's momma  |   Posted on Jun 8th, 2007

    Judas Priest drove my son to suicide.

  12. homegirrl  |   Posted on Jun 9th, 2007

    Pete Doherty gave me AIDs.

  13. a pedestrian pedestrian  |   Posted on Jun 9th, 2007

    CSS failed to yield the right of way to me as I crossed the street.

  14. Steve  |   Posted on Jun 9th, 2007

    Emily Haines stole my vagina.

  15. Sharon Osbourne hurt my feelings.

  16. Dr. Venture  |   Posted on Jun 9th, 2007

    David Bowie stole my panda’s milk!!!

  17. DWilly  |   Posted on Jun 9th, 2007

    “Judas Priest drove my son to suicide.”

    WELL PLAYED

    David Bowie knocked over my bookcase.

  18. Pitchforkmedia stole my pitchfork

    Also, both the accusing and William War III have had their blogs taken down.

  19. Google took down my blog.

  20. soybomb  |   Posted on Jun 11th, 2007

    Thom Yorke stared awkwardly at me

  21. Sufjan Stevens exploited my bone cancer.

  22. The Postal Service failed to deliver my mail.

  23. Marilyn Manson  |   Posted on Jun 12th, 2007

    Gerard Way stole my Rit Dye!

  24. Nina Simone  |   Posted on Jun 12th, 2007

    antony stole my vibratto!

  25. jesus  |   Posted on Jun 12th, 2007

    Andrew Bird pooped on me!

  26. Some white dude made a funny about a cool, edgy band doing the nasty with his fill-in-the-blank, which made me feel “in” — until some black dude played the race card and then I felt guilty.

  27. pippa  |   Posted on Jun 13th, 2007

    morrissey rang around my fountain

    apples in stereo “borrowed” my fruit bowl

    neutral milk hotel flooded my hotel room with various forms of dairy

    ben kweller is wearing my sundress

    various indie bands did me wrong in one way or another

  28. word to your mother  |   Posted on Jun 13th, 2007

    The title of that Smiths song is “Reel Around the Fountain,” dummy. And your other so-called quips aren’t funny, either.

  29. Stephen  |   Posted on Jun 13th, 2007

    Queens of the Stone Age stole my flintstones vitamins.

  30. Sufjan Stevens ate up all of Pitchfork’s time.

  31. Scotta  |   Posted on Jun 13th, 2007

    Broken Social Scene caused the break up of my various emo bands.

  32. TB Guy  |   Posted on Jun 13th, 2007

    Rufus Wainright sneezed on me.

  33. A Different Nathan  |   Posted on Jun 14th, 2007

    Yo La Tengo got its name from baseball

    arcadefirestolemybaseball.blogspot.com

    Joanna Newsom stole a monkey and a bear from a zoo

    Leslie Feist made my mush go boom

    Sonic Youth fooled me into thinking they are young when they are actually quite old

    J Mascis stole my safety scissors but he did not use them to cut his hair

    Cat Power made me sneeze because I’m allergic

    Hot Chip burnt my tongue

    Minus the Bear would rather Joanna only steal a monkey

    Pedro the Lion fooled me into thinking he was a lion when he is actually a human similar to Sonic Youth

    Elliott Smith… sorry nothing is funny about a guy dying

    Spoon helped me eat my cereal

    TV on the Radio is just not possible

    Patrick Wolf fooled me into thinking he was a wolf when he is actually a human very similar to Pedro the Lion

  34. The New Pornographers called in sick and I had to work their closing shift.

  35. alex  |   Posted on Jun 14th, 2007

    the hold steady almost killed me.

  36. alex  |   Posted on Jun 14th, 2007

    Relatedly, who killed the Zutons?

  37. everlone  |   Posted on Jun 14th, 2007

    The Who killed Bambi

  38. Bruce  |   Posted on Jun 15th, 2007

    This comment thread has jumped the shark

  39. Bobby McObvious  |   Posted on Jun 15th, 2007

    Colin Meloy failed to lock up my bicycle. Now it’s at the bottom of a French town pond, rudely abused on some Hessian’s joyride.

  40. ladyfinger  |   Posted on Jun 15th, 2007

    The Flaming Lips irritated by VD

  41. as requested, the “sufjan stevens broke my hockey stick” t-shirt:

    http://www.zazzle.com/johnsonl33/product/235150927162651986

  42. Mike  |   Posted on Jun 17th, 2007

    Wilco told me a really offensive racist joke.

  43. Josh  |   Posted on Jun 18th, 2007

    Devandra Banhart pissed in my pool.

  44. Mike Bloomberg ruined my chances of becoming President.

  45. Franklin Bruno ate all my cookie dough.

    No, really: http://www.matadorrecords.com/escandalo/5/reviewsbands.html

  46. jack white stole my tanning bed

  47. …and oddly enough here is video evidence of said “Arcade Fire” with the Win Butler in question playing with a basketball! Filmed by Guerrilla Remote! http://www.youtube.com/user/guerrillaremote?feature=mhee#p/u/1/42Zr-8X1SUw

  48. …and oddly enough here is a video of “Arcade Fire” and one Win Butler playing basketball, Filmed by Guerrilla Remote. http://www.youtube.com/user/guerrillaremote?feature=mhee#p/u/1/42Zr-8X1SUw

Leave a Reply

Login

You must be logged in to post, reply to, or rate a comment.

%s1 / %s2