Chris Garneau Covers Elliott Smith
Chris Garneau's promising debut record ends in tribute to the incomparable Elliott Smith, putting a classical spin on the troubled, Either/Or ballad "Between The Bars," turning it into a slow, fragile piano waltz.
Chris Garneau - "Between The Bars" (MP3)
Nothing's gonna hold up to Elliott, ever -- but Chris's vulnerable vocal and subtle rephrasing makes it worth a listen. Maybe you'll like. Either way tell us your favorite Elliott cover, or if his songs should never be touched. If the latter, that's just 'cause you haven't heard KoRn's version of "Angeles" yet.
Posted at 6:09 PM in MP3
Tags: Chris Garneau | Elliott Smith
Metric does a good cover of this.
Ben Folds does a mean Say Yes.
Score = 0
This pussy is going to have to do three times the amount of drugs Elliott did in his lifetime to get anywhere close.
Score = -1
Madeleine Peyroux does a really good "Between the Bars". Shit is gold.
Score = 0
jesus, chris has the most amazingly fragile voice. sometimes when i'm listening to him i'm convinced that his is the most beautiful voice ever.
Score = 0
sacrilege. same with madeleine peyroux's cover.
christopher o'riley comes close to doing the original justice.
Score = 0
or grant buell, for example.
http://www.sendspace.com/file/4lzn8x
but this cover is execrable.
Score = 0
affectation. i can't imagine anyone actually choosing to sound like joanna newsome.
Score = 0
thanks to those who mentioned the madeleine pyroux cover. one time when i was in germany at 3 in the morning, late for a train, i hailed a cab and as i shit myself with every passing minute i was getting closer to missing the train, that cover came on the radio and it was amazing. made me feel so much better, and i could never find it online or anything.
Score = 0
Madeleine Peyroux's cover of "Between the Bars" is really good. Explores the song from a slightly different angle and it works.
Score = 0
Nah... sounds like he? she? is trying too hard to pull a Dresden Dolls, but DD could probably make the tune more interesting.
Score = 0
I think this cover is mediocre at best, but the rest of Chris Garneau's album is so hair-raisingly spooky-good. Especially "Not Nice." Fuck, what an affecting song. I do think he and Elliott have more than a bit in common.
Does anyone know if it's true that Elliott Smith once tried to jump off a cliff and landed on a tree, which saved his life and scarred his face? I heard it somewhere once and have repeated it many times. Now I'm starting to worry that it's not true ... confirm or deny? Bueller?
Score = 0
his face is scarred cause he had acne, it's not some sort of tree-related injury.
so i doubt that story is true at all. why exactly have you "repeated it many times" before making sure it was based on fact?
Score = 0
if i hadnt seen a picture of this guy ida thought he was a chick. this cover is not workin' for me.
Score = 0
tree related incident is definetely true, it happened in north carolina, it was written in roling stone shortly after his death.....
Score = 0
i'm actually on the hunt for as many between the bars covers as i can possibly find.
even though elliott will always be a million times better.
hm, i need to find the metric one on mp3.
Score = 0
His show today at Bowery was kind of boring.
Score = 0
I agree that it doesn't hold up to the original, but the rest of Garneau's album, "Music for Tourists" is amazing. He's so graceful and sad, I love it. I can't get enough of "So Far" and "Not Nice."
Score = 0
pitchfork gives it a 2.3
i'm glad someone still has their head on straight... this music makes me projectile vomit.
"But hidden track 'Between the Bars' is [a cover], and cries out for a metronome as the singer takes a melodramatic shit on the aforementioned Smith's fucked-up memory."
http://pitchforkmedia.com/article/record_review/41471/Chris_Garneau_Music_for_Tourists
Score = 0
I actually like the cover better live... in this video from Blogotheque, it just sounds better: http://www.blogotheque.net/article.php3?id_article=2889
Score = 0
By the way, what Metric album has between the bars on it?
Score = 0
I'm not sure whether that post by Marianna Jane Close (UK) is a joke or not. But either way it's just stupid and pointless.
Please do something better with your time.
Score = 0
I love you to Marianna.
Score = 0
1.) Are you shitting me!? "The Dresdon Dolls could have made the tune more interesting"? That is the most absurd thing i've ever seen written in the english language. I'm afraid to even read it out loud for fear of spontaneous combustion. Congratulations to Alex for leaving by far the dumbest comment on this entire page, good luck with the rest of your endeavors.
2.) It's a cover. It's not suppose to be better than the original. It's a token of one artists admiration for another. Look at Chris Garneaus' original work if your going to judge him. Love Zombies is one of the best songs to come out in 2007 easily.
3.) I can't believe I left a comment on one of these stupid message boards, I never do this, but what that kid said was so inane. His comment should be deleted from this message board because it is not worth a dragons' queef in a ball jar.
4.) Look how tough STEVEN is, 2nd comment down, that's one cool mother fucker alright.
Score = 0