Pantheon Awards
I kept wondering why everyone was talking about the Pantheon Awards, as I'd never heard of 'em. Turns out Pantheon Is The New Shortlist, which recognizes under-the-radar albums (less than 500k copies sold domestically between 7/1/04 and 10/30/05).
Pantheon Awards: Top Ten FinalistsThe finalists were voted on by a panel of musicians, journalists, and O.C. cast and crew. Collectively, they have the same taste in music as you.
Animal Collective Feels (Fatcat)
Antony and the Johnsons I Am A Bird Now (Secretly Canadian)
Arcade Fire Funeral (Merge)
Bloc Party Silent Alarm (Vice)
Death Cab For Cutie's Plans (Atlantic)
Decemberists Picaresque (Kill Rock Stars)
Fiona Apple Extraordinary Machine (Epic)
Kings Of Leon Aha Shake Heartbreak (RCA)
M.I.A. Arular (XL/Beggars Banquet)
Sufjan Stevens Illinois (Asthmatic Kitty)
Pitchfork recommends hitting newpantheon.net to see which panelists nominated which records ("who knew ?uestlove dug Bright Eyes and Suzanne Vega is a Jamiroquai fan?!").
Re: image above, Presumably I visited the site while they were making a page code update, but it's amusing to think they didn't bother to put Actor On The O.C.'s name.
Posted at 11:53 AM
Tags: Animal Collective | Arcade Fire | Bloc Party | Fiona Apple
yesterday it had his name but only said "Actor on" underneath it.
Score = 0
Who the fuck is Z-Trip?! Shinoda and that other guy from Linkin Park are both reccomending this, and I'm venturing to guess that they are some kind of tour mate or side project.
I'm going out on a limb here, but I smell a "plug". And if not that, then shameless ass kissing.
Who said those two guys have taste anyways?
Score = 0
What the HELL are the guys from Linkin Park doing on this panel?
Score = 0
I think they were getting cutsey on the titles, like graphic designers who put "toybuilder" or "creative type" on their business cards. Ric Ocasek made some nice choices. I just heart him so much.
Score = 0
I resent your suggestion that i allow the cast and crew of the O.C. to influence my taste in music. These waters must remain pure.
Score = 0
Geez, what a circle-jerk.
Score = 0
Z-Trip is a DJ. Turntablist. Whatever.
Score = 0
How does everyone know that we're not the ones influencing the OC and not the other way around. Hmmm ....
Score = 0
"Z-Trip's most recent release, Shifting Gears, marked his major label debut. Released on Hollywood Records in 2005, the album features guest artists Supernatural, MURS, Lyrics Born, Luke Sick, Aceyalone, Mystic, Prince Whipper Whip, Busdriver, Chester Bennington (from Linkin Park), Chuck D (from Public Enemy) and Soup (from Jurassic 5)."
I knew it...
Score = 0
keith urban's handle is "international superstar"?!? apparently you get to fill in your own title, unless he is an international superstar and i'm out of the loop (which is entirely possible).
good to see ?uestlove on the panel... that dude is awesome.
and arcade fire's gotta win this thing, no? i can't see an album out of that list that has had more cultural impact. then again, i'm canadian so maybe i'm a bit biased. O_O
Score = 0
It'll be interesting to see the last two years' hipster darlings Funeral and Illinois go head to head. But I would vote Funeral all the way.
Score = 0
i love margaret cho as a comedian, but as a musical beacon?
*ponder*
Score = 0
shes not even good as a comedian...
woo kings of leon!
Score = 0
So, Keith Urban? Totally famous. He's dating Nicole Kidman, which makes him tabloid fodder on at least two continents.
At least that explains the "international" part of his title. I don't know what he's done to deserve "superstar."
Score = 0
i'd like to see ?uestlove produce the next bloc party record....
speaking of the roots...
whatever happened to malik b?
Score = 0
Every once in a while, I try to track down any recent Malik B sightings on the web... all I've been able to find is that he's now going by the name "Imillitant" and he's featured along with Black Thought on an upcoming (?) track by someone named Maylay Sparks.
http://www.fatbeats.com/catalog/product_info.php?manufacturers_id=149&products_id=1528
I'm still crossing fingers that he'll end up back in the group one of these days...
Score = 0
not enough wolf parade on those lists.
Score = 0
Horrible Linkin Park collabo aside, that Z-Trip record is pretty nice.
Score = 0
who is z-trip???
his album that came out this year was disappointing, but that guy was making some of the best mashups and blends for a while.
Score = 0
it's positively shocking that Margaret Cho would vote for Le Tigre.
Score = 0
apparently some of you have never been to the short list website when they would have the lists by all the people who nominated the albums...i don't recall linkin park being part of short list, but some of the voters were pretty "mainstream"
anyways, my vote goes to arcade fire hands down. i glanced at the list and didn't have to think for a second.
Score = 0
wow, almost as self-congratulatory and unnecessary as the Short List
Score = 0
Z-Trip is a professional asshole.
Score = 0
christ, why don't more irrelevent celebrities listen to animal collective or andrew bird
Score = 0
where the heck is Z by My Morning Jacket?
no respect i tell ya.
Score = 0
don't worry, at least dave picked up jim james and crew
Score = 0
I knew that Dave Mathews would pick Mike Doughty's album before I even looked; it's on his label. douchy.
Score = 0
Yeah, when I clicked on Matthews I was wondering if there'd be a bunch of ATO records. Uh-huh. Oh well, "Z" deserved to be on the list.
I appreciate the fact that Pinback's great album got a few nominations, even though they released their album near the beginning of the eligibility period.
There were a lot of big-label artists that were probably only on the list because their album was released just before the eligibility period ended. I expect they'll be gone next year, either hitting gold (DCFC) or being forgotten (Fiona?).
Score = 0
It's tricky. Chances are that artists will collaborate with others (or outright sign them to their own labels) when they like them, but then there's that question---when they recommend them, how much is it genuine admiration and how much is shameless plug? Ah, how commericalization corrupts everything! :P
Score = 0
Is oink gone or just down.
Score = 0
No one will give a damn about New Pantheon, just like no one really cared about The Shortlist award. Run by the same idiots after all. I'll give an award for dumbest award show name ever.
Score = 0
Keith Urban must merit as an 'international superstar' considering he's an Australian who makes music for Americans.
Score = 0
I say you gotta give it up for Animal Collective - Feels out of those choices, but there is no way in hell it will win with those dorky judges...2 guys from Linkin Park??? Hasn't it been established already that they don't know good music just by listening to an album of theirs?
Score = 0
Suzanne Vega? Yeah, it offers more insight to go to itunes and see what's these guy's playlists are. And where are the more intelligent "under the radar" musicians...how about aimee mann or something
what a load of rubbish. andrian brody. pfft.
Score = 0
I'm going to venture that all award shows are self-promoting garbage. How unsurprising is this list of nominees? About as shocking as a Pitchfork best-of. I think Animal Collective, Antony, and Arcade Fire deserve it, but as much as I enjoy the Decemberists, Death Cab (Plans was pretty bleh), and Sufjan, they're not exactly pushing any boundaries. These kinds of shows won't be interesting until folks stop being so damn conservative with their choices. I mean, Damien Rice? And who's going to remember Bloc Party in five years? I think half of the indie rock world these days has as much lasting impact and staying power as Elastica.
Score = 0
"Is oink gone or just down."
Gone? Im sure youve been through this before.
Score = 0
I would pick Mensware or Starsailor before Elastica, after all the Frisch has many ramifications and aftershocks still trembling throughout the british music world. (Plus she is the reason everyone has heard of Wire's Pink Flag now.)
Score = 0
Exactly what radar have these bands fallen under? Anyone who will ever hear or care about the Patheon Awards doesn't need them.
Plus the title is a complete misnomer since admission to the Pantheon, by definition, would require that you're already famous.
Score = 0
how is this list even really relavant? Isnt this just a bunch of people giving some "award" to bands we already know and listen to?
Years past the short list always seemed to only be seen by us (the readers of stereogum, fluxblog, etc).
I guess i just dont undestand it.
Score = 0
Singer George Michael lends the piano on which John Lennon wrote Imagine to an anti-war exhibition...
Score = 0