Profile 
surlyduck
Website: -
Find Me On:

Comments

 +15Posted on Mar 4th | re: Amanda Palmer's TED Talk: What We Learned (48 comments)

What I learned: those “eyebrows” of hers are still really frightening.

 +3Posted on Feb 19th | re: Fainting By Numbers - "A Stone In The Ground" (2 comments)

I love it! And that bassline sounds an awful lot like the Twin Peaks theme.

 -1Posted on Dec 17th, 2012 | re: The xx - "Last Christmas" (Wham! Cover) (14 comments)

Ugh, their shtick is so tired now. Zzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzzz….

 -2Posted on Oct 22nd, 2012 | re: The 10 Best Leonard Cohen Songs (45 comments)

Considering picks from certain albums, I would have picked “Chelsea Hotel” > “Who By Fire” and “Take This Waltz” > “Tower of Song”. “Hallelujah” is a great song, but let’s face it, JB’s cover makes Cohen’s version pale in comparison.

 +4Posted on Aug 28th, 2012 | re: The 12 Best Acts At Electric Zoo That Aren't Skrillex, Tiesto, Or Diplo (4 comments)

I’m a little sad that you’ve grouped Diplo together with Tiesto and Skrillex, two of the cheesiest DJs in EDM.

 -1Posted on Aug 8th, 2012 | re: The 10 Best Blur Songs (134 comments)

This list is so wrong on so many levels.

“Girls & Boys”, “End of A Century”, “To The End”, “Coffee & TV”, “Beetlebum” and “Tender” might all be obvious choices, but they’re also the right choices. You just can’t fuck with classics.

 0Posted on Jun 18th, 2012 | re: Let's Shortlist The Indie Song Of The Summer 2012 (336 comments)

Agreed. Dent May should be getting way more love. “Do Things” is a terrific summer album.

 +2Posted on Jun 17th, 2012 | re: Let's Shortlist The Indie Song Of The Summer 2012 (336 comments)

Grimes – “Oblivion”. I don’t care if it’s >6 months old now, it still rules.

 +8Posted on Jun 12th, 2012 | re: Premature Evaluation: Fiona Apple The Idler Wheel... (18 comments)

Music for people that listen for lyrics

 0Posted on May 30th, 2012 | re: Stream Fight Bite's New LP (22 comments)

I was wondering the same thing. She’s definitely one of my biggest indie crushes of recent memory. Score one for the spank bank!

 +1Posted on May 25th, 2012 | re: Dave Matthews Band - "Gaucho" (159 comments)

Having discerning taste in music and being a hipster are not at all the same thing. This is primarily an independent music blog, so when you see posts about DMB without any irony, it’s bound to raise a few eyebrows.

I hate your statement, your avatar, and probably wouldn’t like you either.

 -2Posted on May 24th, 2012 | re: Stereogum's Top 25 Albums Of 2012 So Far (328 comments)

Nope.

 +3Posted on May 23rd, 2012 | re: Stereogum's Top 25 Albums Of 2012 So Far (328 comments)

I’d get rid of Sleigh Bells and Chairlift and include Porcelain Raft, Mount Eerie, Lemonade and Pond

Chromatics should both be WAY higher on the list too. Definitely Top 5 IMO.

 +2Posted on Mar 19th, 2012 | re: In Defense Of Skrillex (286 comments)

“Yeah, well that’s just, like, your opinion, man.”

Nope. She’s pretty abysmal. I’m simply saying there have been plenty of artists of mediocre talent that put out amazing music.

I think that’s giving Carles too much credit. I haven’t really read HRO since the “Great Electro Wars of 2007″ and I’m still perfectly capable of judging her. I took note when there was that long letter from Amy Klein of Titus Andronicus floating around that questioned LDR’s authenticity.

What does any of this have to do with HRO or being a city dweller? Hope all is well in Podunk, IA… Say hello to Auntie Mae for me!

Sorry if I offended your sensibilities, Judith Bulter. It just made me laugh.

Being a talented musician and being worth listening to are two very different things. If being a talented musician was all that mattered to people, then Dream Theater or some shit would be like the biggest band in the world. It’s not about complicated time signatures or minor keys or whatever else music students at Julliard jerk off to. What makes music resonate with people is completely subjective.

Actually, I would argue that she would fit right in with the kind of artists that perform on SNL: palatable pop for the mainstream and tremendously popular for no good reason

I felt compelled to copy this gem of a comment from a Brooklyn Vegan:

“I question the heterosexuality of any dude that didn’t enjoy her performance. Sorry frumpy chicks, Adele can’t be dragged away from the buffet to be on every week.”

 +6Posted on Jan 5th, 2012 | re: 10 Classic Albums Released 10 Years Into A Band's Career (131 comments)

Listen to Piper at the Gates of Dawn, their first album with Syd Barrett still in the band. Certainly made me a believer.

 +3Posted on Jan 5th, 2012 | re: 10 Classic Albums Released 10 Years Into A Band's Career (131 comments)

The exactly 10 year rule is kind of arbitrary here. However, I think a longer list (100?) of classic albums after 10+ years of an artist’s existence is a worthwhile exercise in itself.

 +5Posted on Dec 8th, 2011 | re: The Big Pink Cover Smashing Pumpkins' "Mayonaise" (12 comments)

My favorite Pumpkins song! The original is so good it makes it nearly impossible to do a proper cover version. I like Big Pink, but I’m sorry to say that they’ve failed here.

 -1Posted on Dec 8th, 2011 | re: Rolling Stone's 50 Best Albums Of 2011 (117 comments)

Pretty much what I expected. Any “best of” list with Lady Gaga on it is immediately invalidated in my book. However, the inclusion of Little Dragon, Tom Waits, Panda Bear, Kurt Vile, Fleet Foxes and Destroyer shows that at least someone on the RS payroll has taste.