Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments

Shut Up, Dude: This Week’s Best And Worst Comments

Coachella is here! And comment voting is back! Two reasons to celebrate for sure. Back in my day, Coachella was only one weekend, and bottled water was only a nickel. If you’re in Indio, don’t forget to drink water (and don’t eat your wristband). Also say hi to Danny DeVito for me. If you’re not there, this is a great weekend to hang out at Stereogum.com: in additional to Coachella recaps and photos from Claire and Andrew, we have a new and improved comment voting system. Hover over the thumbs for a comment and you can see how many upvotes and downvotes it got. Exciting, right? Less exciting than Blur/more exciting than RHCP? Anyway, before we get to the list, here’s what happened in our world this week:

Here are the highest and lowest rated responses to all of those things!

THIS WEEK’S 10 HIGHEST RATED COMMENTS

#10

Jim Rountree | Apr 8th Score:17

eh. i mean, that’s arguable. she turned their economy around, but for who? also, i’m pretty sure shutting down the mining towns in northern england and leaving hundreds of thousands of people without jobs or really any kind of future wasn’t her only option on how to handle their woes back then.

also, nice jab on me being from texas. you’re right, there are no liberals here at all and we all carry guns and yell at gay people as they’re trying to take their mail out.

Posted in: Morrissey: “Margaret Thatcher Was A Terror Without An Atom Of Humanity”
#9

Ben Cornell | Apr 10th Score:18

well, you really fucked me on that one, non-moving gif.

Posted in: The 10 Best National Songs
#8

Jim Rountree | Apr 8th Score:19

well. he’s right. she, in tandem with ronald reagan, waged a war on the middle/lower class that is STILL not over with today. both their policies are reflected in their current parties today. but thatcher was worse. instead of working with the opposition she waged scorched earth on them. that’s why most of northern britain lost their livelihoods back then.

Posted in: Morrissey: “Margaret Thatcher Was A Terror Without An Atom Of Humanity”
#7

Chris DeVille | Apr 11th Score:20

Good to know. I’m going to keep singing “Fallin’, fallin’, fallin.’”

Posted in: Deconstructing: Phoenix And The Festival Headliner Economy
#6 velvet1965 | Apr 10th Score:21

this could not be further from the ten best National songs. listen to something other than High Violet.

Posted in: The 10 Best National Songs
#5

Stephen Berry | Apr 8th Score:22

These guys have already passed into “Can Do No Wrong” territory, right? Yes, this is pretty awesome

Posted in: The National – “Demons”
#4 b-rar | Apr 8th Score:22

She supported Apartheid and called Mandela a terrorist. Every day she walked the earth was one too many.

Posted in: Morrissey: “Margaret Thatcher Was A Terror Without An Atom Of Humanity”
#3

Travus White | Apr 8th Score:23

I’m pretty sure everything they do is perfect.

Posted in: The National – “Demons”
#2

Nick Burica | Apr 8th Score:25

I was joking, this tune is great. I just wanted to make sure the new downvotes worked.

Posted in: The National – “Demons”
#1

John Voci | Apr 8th Score:25

Haha yep! Well said!

Just gotta wrap it up with a little…

Posted in: Morrissey: “Margaret Thatcher Was A Terror Without An Atom Of Humanity”

THIS WEEK’S 5 LOWEST RATED COMMENTS

#5

Taylor Adams | Apr 8th Score:-8

I thought you said this was for ‘Mericans, not nerds, loser.

Posted in: Morrissey: “Margaret Thatcher Was A Terror Without An Atom Of Humanity”
#4

Danny Devereauxx | Apr 11th Score:-8

no one makes dad music quite like the national!

Posted in: The National – “Don’t Swallow The Cap”
#3 copy_paster_cat | Apr 8th Score:-10

yeah. this is just dull. really annoying video too

Posted in: The National – “Demons”
#2

Rob Casper | Apr 10th Score:-10

you mean TERRIBLE LOVE (JUST IN CASE OUR LABEL REQUESTS A RADIO SINGLE VERSION)

Posted in: The 10 Best National Songs
#1

Rahbrrt Kahtinn | Apr 10th Score:-15

Boooooooooo-Riiiiiiiiiiiiiiing

Posted in: The 10 Best National Songs

THIS WEEK’S EDITOR’S CHOICE (SCOTT)

KiDCHAIR | 1:28pm Score:1

Can I just say I’m pretty glad to see that Paramore video up there? I’ve been secretly jamming to that song/video for the last couple days and was kind of starting to wonder about my future. Good call. Catchy as hell and she’s adorable.

Posted in: The 5 Best Videos Of The Week

more from Shut Up, Dude: This Week's Best Comments