The Killers just released their career-spanning best-of Direct Hits, and they included two new songs on the album. One of those songs, the M83 collab “Shot At The Night,” already had a glitzy music video with a kinda-famous actress in it. And now the second new one, the surging “Just Another Girl,” has Glee actress Dianna Agron starring as different incarnations of Killers frontman Brandon Flowers throughout the band’s history. But then the actual Flowers is in it, too. It’s confusing. Watch it below.

Direct Hits is out now on Island.