Hozier was the musical guest for the second time on Saturday Night Live this weekend, 10 years after he first took Studio 8H to church. He performed his No. 1 hit “Too Sweet,” and — because he’s Irish and in New York and it was the Christmas episode — he did a cover of the Pogues and Kirsty MacColl’s “Fairytale Of New York,” the holiday ballad co-written by the late Shane MacGowan.

And Hozier wasn’t the only guest returning to SNL this episode: former cast member Martin Short was the host, making him the newest member of the Five-Timers Club. A whole bunch of fellow Five-Timers — Tom Hanks, Melissa McCarthy, Paul Rudd, Emma Stone, Scarlett Johansson, Tina Fey, John Mulaney, and Alec Baldwin — plus Jimmy Fallon made cameos to induct him during the cold open, making for great family viewing. Watch it below.

Elsewhere Lucy Liu appeared in a pre-taped How The Grinch Stole Christmas sendup, Bowen Yang sang some Wicked as a drone, and the annual Weekend Update joke swap — in which Colin Jost and Michael Che write off-color jokes for each other to deliver — had Che expressing solidarity with Diddy.