A couple of months ago, the new Britt Daniel/Dan Boeckner/Sam Brown supergroup Divine Fits made their triumphant late-night debut, playing the everliving shit out of the Daniel-sung single “Would That Not Be Nice” on Fallon. On Friday night, they showed up on broadcast television again, and this time Boeckner got to take a turn on lead vocals. As musical guests on Letterman, the band played a terse and locked-in rendition of their song “Baby Get Worse,” impressing yet again. Watch the performance below.

Divine Fits’ debut album A Thing Called Divine Fits is out now on Merge.