Rookie Mag, the progressive online publication for teenage girls that picks up where Sassy Magazine left off, has an on-going column called “Ask A Grown Man,” in which celebrities field questions from their readers and offer advice from a seasoned perspective. Past guests have included Jimmy Fallon, Community’s Danny Pudi, and an especially-awkward Jon Hamm. This time around, Rookie got Thom Yorke and Nigel Godrich who are hilariously dry, but helpful. Watch below as they tackle topics like crushes, boring relationships, and deodorant brand suggestions.