Tori Amos covered Radiohead’s “Creep” during a show at The Beacon Theater in New York on Wednesday night. The Grammy-nominated singer, who released her fourteenth album Unrepentant Geraldines earlier this year, is no stranger to the band: She previously covered “Karma Police” back in 2005. Watch Amos sing the Radiohead classic below.

Unrepentant Geraldines is out now via Mercury Classics.