Deer Tick wrapped up the year and their six-night Brooklyn Bowl residency with a surprise guest appearance by Stevie Nicks. She came out during their New Year’s Eve show to sing “Rhiannon” with the band, who were celebrating their tenth anniversary with a series of shows to pay tribute to the artists that inspired them. Nicks is a long-time friend of the band: Last year, she officiated frontman John McCauley’s wedding to Vanessa Carlton. Watch the performance below.