Last weekend, as Florence + The Machine were playing the Coachella main stage just before Drake’s headlining spot, Florence Welch broke her foot. If you were watching the show, you would’ve had no idea anything had happened; she still showed a ton of energy. Last night, Welch played the second Coachella weekend, and she seemed super-apologetic that she couldn’t do the same thing. She had to play a slightly truncated set, and she remained seated the whole time. But she did pull out something special: An appearance from fellow Coachella performer Father John Misty, who joined her onstage for a stripped-down acoustic cover of Nazareth’s classic 1975 power ballad “Love Hurts.” Watch the lighters-up moment unfold below.

Florence’s new album How Big How Blue How Beautiful is out 6/2 on Republic.