In some of the darkest corners of the internet — like, say, the Stereogum comments section — you will find conspiracy theorists digging deep into the numerology behind the long-running Omaha funk-rock band 311. And now Eric André, host of Adult Swim’s absurdist late-night talk show The Eric André Show, has taken it upon himself to “investigate 311.” This investigation involves waterboarding, magnifying glasses, and baseball bat attacks, all while the real 311 perform the once-inescapable 1995 hit “Down.” Watch the brief and ridiculous segment below.

When it comes to enhanced interrogation, you’ve got to trust your instincts.