Maggie Rogers specializes in a deeply pleasing blend of electronic pop and coffeehouse folk music, but like most of us, she has a soft spot for the Spice Girls. During her debut festival performance at Firefly yesterday, Rogers and a former NYU classmate named Fletcher covered the UK girl group’s 1996 breakout “Wannabe.” Here’s some keen scene-setting from our friends at Billboard:

“This is the first festival I’ve ever played,” Maggie Rogers told the crowd. With her eyes painted in electric blue eyeshadow, Rogers sang songs off her debut EP Now That The Light Is Fading, such “Dog Days” and “On and Off.” Halfway through the set she gushed, “I just don’t think I’m going to get over this” before throwing on a pair of red-tinted shades. She then invited her friend and former New York University classmate, Fletcher, on stage with her to energize the audience with a cover of The Spice Girls’ “Wannabe.” She ended with the fan-favorite (and career-launching) “Alaska,” which came out a year ago to the day.

Below, enjoy footage of the cover, which sounds more like gleeful karaoke to me.

billboard: Tfw when maggierogers and findingfletcher cover the Spice Girls at LiveAtFirefly 😍 pic.twitter.com/kfy9fLxVY6

— Music Youtube (@Music_maestro) June 15, 2017

.@findingfletcher just joined her school classmate @maggierogers on stage for an adorable cover of Spice Girls' "Wannabee" 🙌🏽#Firefly2017 pic.twitter.com/VA0aThkgvI

— Promo Bi. (@BiancaEnRogue) June 15, 2017

@maggierogers and @findingfletcher singing "Wanna Be" = pure gold. #SLAM 🙌🏻🙌🏻🙌🏻 pic.twitter.com/ahuxOvpJrr

— Becky Turek (@beckyturek) June 16, 2017

this is the face my soul is making about playing my first ever festival. i did a triple spin and everyone knew the words and it was better than I ever could have imagined. @fireflymusicfestival, with all of me, thank you. i'll never forget this night. 💕

A post shared by Maggie Rogers (@maggierogers) on Jun 15, 2017 at 7:26pm PDT