‘Tis the season for Halloween cover shows, and last night’s at Shea Stadium in Brooklyn was stacked: Emily Reo covered Carly Rae Jepsen, Charly Bliss were Josie & The Pussycats, Pouty was Madonna, and Sharpless took on Kate Bush. All of the sets were magical, but I gotta give it up for my girl Carly (and Emily), who ran through a bunch of E•MO•TION tracks (plus “Call Me Maybe,” of course) with not one, not two, but three keytars and a whole lot of reverence for the Queen Of Halloween. Below, watch some video of them doing “I Really Like You,” “Boy Problems” (with Speedy Ortiz’s Sadie Dupuis and Sharpless’ Montana Levy on backup vocals), “Run Away With Me,” and a compilation video of all the sets from the night.

"Boy Problems" from @emilyreo's @carlyraejepsen Halloween cover set. #keytar #threetar #CarlyRaeJepsen pic.twitter.com/4CjAvPdcdQ

— sabine's mom (@B3byVoldemort) November 1, 2016

.@carlyraejepsen @emilyreo All Carly Rae Halloween set. pic.twitter.com/FlDRLydTZL

— Zack Sabbath (@Zack_Sabbath) November 1, 2016

@carlyraejepsen yoooooooooo check out this @emilyreo Halloween cover set of CRJ smash hits maybe lol #emotional #whoisshe #shareifyouagree pic.twitter.com/ZkNHKEPmaa

— Jeff Fleisher (@JeffFleisher) November 1, 2016

And here’s the compilation video — Sharpless, Pouty, Emily Reo, and Charly Bliss, in that order: