American Horror Story began it’s foray into “freak show” territory last week and seems to be adopting some traditions from Ryan Murphy’s other show, Glee, by featuring a lot of musical performances (and then selling them on iTunes later on to make more money). In last week’s season premiere, Jessica Lange performed a creepy cover of David Bowie’s “Life On Mars,” and this week Sarah Paulson’s double-headed twin character sang Fiona Apple’s “Criminal.” Murphy hinted on Twitter that Lange would be covering Lana Del Rey later in the season, but there’s no word on what other spooky covers the American Horror Story crew will dream up. Watch “Criminal” below.